T Techclick ← All lessons
Check Point · Quantum R81.20 / R82 · Lesson 10 of 17

Find the drop: no guessing

Three people have three theories. Nobody opened Logs & Monitor. This lesson is the search that ends the argument: 5-tuple, Action, Rule, Blade, Origin, Xlate. If the drop is not in the log, that is also an answer — logging off, or dropped before the VM (SecureXL lesson).

Updated 2026-08-18·18 min read·L2 primary·Quiz at end

After this page you can

The ticket

Priya → 10.20.30.41:443 fails. Chat: “NAT,” “IPS,” “cluster,” “Windows firewall.” Sixty seconds in SmartLog beats sixty minutes of theory.

Quick interview answer

Filter the 5-tuple in Logs & Monitor. The drop line’s Blade tells you which lesson to open next (Access, NAT, TP, HTTPS, IA). Rule tells you first match. If there is no line, either Track is none or the packet never reached the logged path — then fw monitor / SecureXL.

Lab data · dummy only

SMS sms-lab 10.10.10.5 · cluster VIP 10.10.10.1 (cp-gw-01 10.10.10.2 / cp-gw-02 10.10.10.3) · external 203.0.113.25 · internal LAN 10.20.30.0/24 · HR PC 10.20.30.80 TECHCLICK\priya.hr · HR app 10.20.30.41 hr.techclick-lab.in. Not a live customer.

What a log line is

One connection (or one drop) from one origin gateway. Fields you must be able to point at:

SmartLog vs zdebug vs fw monitor

ToolWhenCost
Logs & MonitorAlways firstLow
fw monitorNeed positions / NAT in pathMedium
fw ctl zdebug + dropDrop with no useful logHigh CPU — short
smartconsole://sms-lab/logs
Training mock · not live
Gateways & ServersSecurity PoliciesLogs & MonitorManage & Settings
Logs & Monitor → Logs

Query

10.20.30.80
10.20.30.41
https
15 minutes
Drop · Blade Firewall · Rule 50 cleanup
SmartConsole Logs & Monitor. Training mock.

Search runbook

  1. Side A — time box

    Ask Priya to click once now. Search last 5 minutes, not last 7 days.

  2. Side B — 5-tuple

    Source 10.20.30.80 dest 10.20.30.41 service https. Open the drop (or the unexpected accept).

  3. Side C — branch

    Blade Firewall + cleanup → rulebase lesson. Blade TP → lesson 9. Empty user → lesson 7. No hit → lessons 11–12.

CLI fallback if GUI logs fail · dummy
fw log -n -l | grep 10.20.30.80
# Still read Action / rule. Do not guess from grep noise.

Four log failures

1 · Track is None

The matching rule does not log. You think there is no traffic. Turn Log on that rule (or a temporary log) for the window.

2 · Wrong origin

You filtered member 2. Traffic is on member 1. Search the cluster or both origins.

3 · Looking at Accept, missing later Drop

Layer 1 Accept, layer 2 / TP Drop. Sort by time, read both blades.

4 · Log server full / forwarding broken

Gateway has local logs. SMS SmartLog empty. fw log on the member.

How to prove it

Close the ticket only when

1) You pasted one log line (or “no log”) into the ticket. 2) Blade + rule named. 3) Next lesson matches that blade. 4) You did not reboot anything yet.

Traps

SymptomLog storyFirst proofWrong fix
No log at allTrack none or pre-VM dropEnable log / fw monitorRebuild policy
Wrong memberOrigin filtercphaprob + OriginReset SIC
Two lines, opposite actionsTwo blades/layersTimestampsIgnore the drop

Knowledge check

Judgment items. One best answer. Reasons send you back to the matching section.

Q1

First tool when users fail?

Correct: a. Always first.
Q2

Which field names the blade that dropped?

Correct: a. Concept.
Q3

No log line after a reproduce. Meaning?

Correct: a. Failure 1 / 12.
Q4

When do you escalate to zdebug?

Correct: a. Choose table.
Q5

Layer 1 Accept and a later Drop. What do you do?

Correct: a. Failure 3.
Q6

Why a 5-minute window?

Correct: a. Runbook Side A.

Check Point class series: Architecture · Gaia first day · SIC reset · Objects + first match · Policy layers · Hide vs Static NAT · Identity Awareness · HTTPS Inspection · Threat Prevention · Find the drop · fw monitor · SecureXL · ClusterXL · VPN Community · Policy install lock · vs PA vs Forti · CCSA / CCSE interview

Sources

Related: Check Point evidence desk · session factory · next lesson in the series above.